Scott Alexander, curated
← Back to curation

The APA Meeting: A Photo-Essay

Quality
78
Excellent
Claude Shift
58
Moderate
RWI
2
of 10
Humor level 2 badge: Man of One StudyHumorMan of One Studya lone chuckle

Follow-up reading

Postscript To APA Photo-Essay — Essay · May 2019

Summary

A celebrated photo-essay on the American Psychiatric Association meeting (15,000 psychiatrists), structured as 'ten things you notice': they all look alike; drug ads cover every surface (the Vraylar(R) running gag); everyone's very woke (a striking list of social-justice sessions — twice as many on global warming as OCD), modeled as a firehose taking pharma money in and shooting social-justice lectures out ('woke capital'); Scientologist protesters spreading ECT myths; a CIA booth; Vraylar(R)'s house-of-cards 'miniature city'; and the sharp centerpiece — the ridiculous me-too drugs (Lucemyra $1,974 vs. clonidine $4.84; 'Dark Ritalin' Jornay $387 vs. $25; Subvenite = lamotrigine-with-instructions $540) and the 6-step 'Healthcaristan SSR' pharma business plan (nobody pays for their own meds). Caps with the 1918 APA presidential address — an unhinged anti-German ('the Hun') rant — showing psychiatry has always been captured by the political fad of the day, yet science advances anyway.

Why this score

Quality 78 · Excellent. Virtuoso SSC reportage — genuinely funny and genuinely informative, with the woke-capital observation, a sharp me-too-drug/pharma-economics exposé, and the excellent 1918-address parallel about psychiatry's perennial political capture. Excellent-low.

Claude’s paradigm shift 58 · Moderate. The 'woke capital firehose' model of the APA, the me-too-drug exposé, and the 1918-parallel payoff are fresh, sharp reportage-observations. Notable.

Real-world impact 2 · Minor. A within-discourse reportage piece; no material-world effect. Within-blog influence.

Humor 2/5 · Man of One Study. A serious reportage piece carried by sustained, prominent intentional humor — the Vraylar(R) running gag, 'AAAAH CAN'T SIT DOWN,' the drug-name litany, the ice-cream bribery. A genuine major feature, secondary to the substance → 2.