Scott Alexander, curated
← Back to curation

More Testimonials For SSC

Quality
54
Solid
Claude Shift
28
Slight
RWI
1
of 10
Humor level 3 badge: Scissor StatementHumorScissor Statementsplits the room

Follows up on

Testimonials for SSC — Humor · Feb 2016

Summary

A comedy compilation: Scott curates the most colorful hostile comments about him and SSC and presents them, ironically, as 'testimonials' (names/links removed to avoid pile-ons). The parade escalates absurdly — 'witless soulsucking fuck,' 'Slate Star Codex is to cognitive dissonance what Goddard was to rocketry,' 'like a giraffe with a head injury loose in Manhattan,' the $500-reward-for-victims bounty — and the contradictions (variously a Nazi and an SJW shill, etc.) quietly make the meta-point that the critics aren't really engaging. A self-deprecating found-comedy piece.

Why this score

Quality 54 · Solid. An enjoyable but slight humor compilation of curated found-material with an ironic framing, plus a light meta-point about the contradictory criticism. Solid, consistent with his other comedic compilations (Search Terms / puns tier ~54).

Claude’s paradigm shift 28 · Slight. A curated-insults humor format; negligible idea novelty. Slight.

Real-world impact 1 · Negligible. A light meta/humor post; no real-world effect. Negligible.

Humor 3/5 · Scissor Statement. Primarily comedic — the whole post is a comedy compilation, and the ironic 'testimonials' framing plus the absurd escalation genuinely land. Scissor-tier, in the Search-Terms vein. 3.