Scott Alexander, curated
← Back to curation

You cannot serve both God and Mammon, but you can serve Mammon by predicting who will serve God

Quality
50
Solid
Claude Shift
20
Slight
RWI
0
of 10
Humor level 2 badge: Man of One StudyHumorMan of One Studya lone chuckle

Summary

A short, early (2013) comedic riff on prediction markets around the 2013 papal conclave: the US bans them (CFTC 'market integrity'), the Vatican excommunicates papal bettors (Gregory XIV's 1591 bull), but Irish books like PaddyPower take action anyway -- offering odds on Richard Dawkins, Bono, and a fictional priest, plus a 'refund if the next Pope is black' promo Scott tries (and fails) to turn into guaranteed money. He concludes he can't find the arbitrage. Entertainment, not analysis.

Why this score

Quality 50 · Solid. Solid floor (50). Genuinely witty (the 'barn door... warped to Andromeda' riff) and competently written, but a tiny, inconsequential topical trifle with no real insight -- Scott himself ends by admitting he can't find the money-pump. The wit lifts it just above a pure stub (RPG-recruitment 44) into the low Solid band with the other slight posts.

Claude’s paradigm shift 20 · Slight. Negligible-Slight (20). A jokey topical post riffing on existing prediction markets; no novel idea in its moment.

Real-world impact 0 · Negligible. 0 -- negligible. A comedic one-off about papal betting; no real-world effect.

Humor 2/5 · Man of One Study. 2 -- gate passes (a light comedic post, not a serious essay with asides), magnitude a genuine chuckle (the Andromeda line, the fictional-priest odds). Not 3 -- wry-amusing, not a sustained or divisive comedy set-piece.