Scott Alexander, curated
← Back to curation

Cryonics without freezers: resurrection possibilities in a Big World

Quality
74
Strong
Claude Shift
50
Moderate
RWI
1
of 10

Summary

A provocative pattern-theory-of-identity piece. The 'consequentialist view of identity': you are 'you' if a being's thoughts and actions match yours, regardless of causal history — so fifty perfect copies are all you, and identity comes in shades of gray (exact clone > different-ice-cream clone > Hindu-fundamentalist clone > LeBron James). Then the three 'Big Worlds' (a very-large/infinite universe with repeating Earth-patches; Many-Worlds QM; modal realism), any of which means copies of you already exist. The payoff, 'cryonics without freezers': if you accept the cryonicist's pattern-identity premise, a Big World is already creating perfect copies of you all the time, so you 'wake up' as the heart-attack-free you next door (or a Friendly AI's quantum-grid copy) without freezing anything — the only cost is reduced measure. And even if Big Worlds are false, the 2050 person most similar to you-now may be closer to Yvain-2012 than Yvain-1995 is, so their waking is itself a kind of resurrection.

Why this score

Quality 74 · Strong. Strong. A clear, genuinely original synthesis (pattern identity + big-world cosmology -> resurrection-without-cryonics) with the sharp gradations-of-identity framing. Pure speculative philosophy with no real-world stakes, and the pattern-identity premise is borrowed from Parfit/Eliezer, so it sits just below the batch's behaviorism standout.

Claude’s paradigm shift 50 · Moderate. Notable — the cryonics-without-freezers move (combining pattern identity with big worlds to reach this conclusion) is a novel 2012 angle; the underlying pattern-identity theory is borrowed.

Real-world impact 1 · Negligible. A clear, original speculative synthesis (pattern-identity plus big-world cosmology yields 'resurrection without cryonics') with a sharp gradations-of-identity framing. Pure speculative philosophy with no real-world stakes — minimal RWI.