Scott Alexander, curated
← Back to curation

In Defense Of "I'm Sorry You Feel That Way"

Quality
72
Strong
Claude Shift
50
Moderate
RWI
2
of 10

Follow-up reading

Highlights From The Comments On "Sorry You Feel That Way" — Highlights (companion) · Sep 2024

Summary

A concise defense of the maligned phrase as the realistic third option (besides caving or being a jerk) for staying firm on the object level while showing compassion. Diagnoses the hatred as 'therapy culture' overfitting norms to one's momentary position - if you wrong someone it's your trauma and they must forgive; if someone wrongs you they're a narcissist to be shunned (citing deBoer). Sharp and useful, if slight.

Why this score

Quality 72 · Strong. Strong: a crisp, genuinely useful reframe of a common discourse move and of 'therapy culture' - short and single-point. ~72.

Claude’s paradigm shift 50 · Moderate. The 'overfitting norms to your current position' diagnosis is a sharp, fresh framing built on deBoer's therapy-culture critique. ~50.

Real-world impact 2 · Minor. A crisp, genuinely useful reframe of a maligned phrase ('I'm sorry you feel that way' as the realistic firm-but-compassionate third option) and of 'therapy culture' overfitting norms to one's momentary position. Conceptual influence within discourse, slight/single-point, no material change — low RWI.