Scott Alexander, curated
← Back to curation

Ye Olde Bay Area House Party

Quality
74
Strong
Claude Shift
38
Slight
RWI
1
of 10
Humor level 4 badge: MolochHumorMolochlaughing helplessly

Follows up on

Son Of Bride Of Bay Area House Party — Humor · Dec 2023

Follow-up reading

Press Any Key For Bay Area House Party — next House Party · Jul 2025

Summary

Sixth entry in the beloved Bay Area House Party satire series, framed by faux-Chaucer Canterbury-Tales verse (spring horniness drives San Franciscans to parties). The usual parade of doomed-or-billion-dollar startups, each skewering a real discourse pattern: the Automated Land Acknowledger pivoting to 'Landulgences' (pay tribes rent to morally launder stolen land); The Burrowing Company (giant ground sloths -> poaching Hamas tunnel-diggers); Stop Talking About Taylor Swift Magazine; the Threads Of Life Foundation, a pitch-perfect reductio of the anti-EA 'but the fish in the bednets!' genre (monitors hunt down African fishermen to free fish from repurposed malaria nets); meta-planning-applications (the real 359,000-page Lower Thames Crossing); the retired-at-25 photographer who took the sinister finger-steepling Elon Musk stock photo; the '11 Nazis at the table' six-degrees reductio (and the @DanielC35801 'driving Jews into the sea is different' hypocrite); and the strongest bit — Diphyllic-Polymer Dam Guy, who cannot answer 'does it shatter at 36 degrees F?' and instead retreats into the Techno-Optimist Manifesto and Tyler Cowen's 'Builder vs. Nervous Nellie' binary, a genuinely incisive satire of how safety questions get dismissed as anti-progress neuroticism.

Why this score

Quality 74 · Strong. Strong, top of the humor tier. Among the funniest and sharpest entries in the series: the Chaucer frame is a real formal flourish, and the Builder/Nervous-Nellie section is pointed social criticism, not just absurdism — it nails the rhetorical move that makes any safety concern un-sayable. Landulgences and Threads-of-Life are precision EA/culture-war satire. Co-tier with Bride-of-Bay-Area-House-Party (74) and My-2024-Presidential-Debate (75); held just under by being an iteration of an established bit. 74.

Claude’s paradigm shift 38 · Slight. Slight-to-moderate. The sixth use of a now-familiar format; novelty is in the targets, not the form. The Builder/Nervous-Nellie point is a fresh framing of a real dynamic, but the post is fundamentally a well-executed series entry, not a new move. 38.

Real-world impact 1 · Negligible. Among the funniest, sharpest 'Bay Area House Party' entries (the Chaucer frame; 'Landulgences'; the Threads-of-Life anti-EA reductio that nails how any safety concern is made un-sayable). Comedic/cultural reach within the rationalist community, no material change — minimal RWI.

Humor 4/5 · Moloch. Bay Area House Party — wall-to-wall satire with Canterbury-Tales pastiche (landulgences, the Burrowing Co. poaching Hamas, fish-in-bednets, meta-planning, the Builder/Nervous-Nellie dam bit) → 4.