Scott Alexander, curated
← Back to curation

Another Bay Area House Party

Quality
73
Strong
Claude Shift
38
Slight
RWI
1
of 10
Humor level 4 badge: MolochHumorMolochlaughing helplessly

Follows up on

Every Bay Area House Party — Humor/Fiction · May 2022

Follow-up reading

Even More Bay Area House Party — next House Party · Jan 2023

Summary

Second entry in the Bay Area House Party series, opening on Pascal ('all human evil comes from inability to sit alone in a room') and the Devil's FOMO stick. Establishes the recurring set-pieces: a procedural-myth-generation LLM startup (with the running 'did Jesus give up when the Minotaur kidnapped his daughter?' AI-generated-mythology gag), SEC-evading financial rap (CA Bill 2799), and the three obligatory cliques — the AI Circle (a sharp riff on whether humans surrender intellect to AI: no, they'll just generate conspiracy theories forever, 'the most human intellectual activity there is'; AI art dismissed because 'our ability to fool ourselves into thinking dumb stuff is cool' outpaces AI's ability to outdo us), the Urbanist Coven (ban stairs, benches, windows), and the EA Nexus (altruistic kidney donation crossed with the Talmud's good-kidney/evil-kidney, and De-Earworm The World's catchy-songs-cause-dementia theory). Lisa the Wikipedia admin's self-referential Hofstadter/Gebstadter paradox is a clean Hofstadter homage. Ends with Skyhook (Fulton STARS rope-extraction from bad dates) as the night's lone future billionaire.

Why this score

Quality 73 · Strong. Strong. Funny and fertile — the AI Circle's conspiracy-theories-as-eudaimonia bit and the self-referential Hofstadter gag have real wit, and the three-coven structure that the series runs on is at full strength. A touch below Ye Olde (74) and Bride (74): more pure absurdist gag-density and less of the pointed social critique that lifts the best entries. 73.

Claude’s paradigm shift 38 · Slight. Slight-to-moderate. An early entry that helped set the series template, but the template itself builds on the first post; the humor is the draw, not novelty of form. 38.

Real-world impact 1 · Negligible. The second 'Bay Area House Party' entry, funny and fertile (the AI-Circle conspiracy-theories-as-eudaimonia bit; the three-coven structure the series runs on). Comedic/cultural reach within the rationalist community, no material change — minimal RWI.

Humor 4/5 · Moloch. Bay Area House Party — wall-to-wall satire (procedural myth generation, the ESG rap, the Wikipedia/Gebstadter paradox, the Urbanist Coven's 'ban windows', Skyhook date-extraction) with a Jesus-and-the-Minotaur runner → 4.